All-Star voting resumed Monday, marking a significant date not just for baseball fans but also for collectors in the hobby. Established superstars like Shohei Ohtani and Aaron Judge have already secured their positions as blue-chip card investments. However, several players stand to experience significant momentum shifts in the card market based on their performances leading up to and during the All-Star festivities. First-time selections, memorable Home Run Derby moments, or standout performances during the All-Star Game itself can cause card prices to skyrocket. Here are the key players collectors should monitor closely as we approach the Midsummer Classic.

Category 1: The Young Studs

Pete Crow-Armstrong (Chicago Cubs)

Pete Crow-Armstrong was always known for his elite defense and speed, but his offensive surge has transformed him from a hyped prospect into a legitimate MVP candidate. His 2020 Bowman Draft #CDA-PC Chrome DP Auto PSA 10 previously ranged from $220-$315 before the season. Currently, this card sells in the $500-$600 range.

This price surge raises an important question: Will the All-Star Game mark his peak? If PCA excels on the national stage, collectors may find this the best-selling opportunity of the year, barring a potential deep playoff run by the Cubs.

Jacob Wilson (Oakland Athletics)

Jacob Wilson, Oakland’s 2023 first-round pick, has rapidly gained attention due to his impressive bat-to-ball skills and unique plate approach. Despite playing for a traditionally weak hobby market, Wilson’s cards have thrived.

• April 2, 2025 - Jacob Wilson 2023 Bowman Draft Chrome 1st Auto PSA 10 sold for $160

• June 26, 2025 -  That same card sold for $510, marking a 218% increase.

Wilson's trajectory makes him a long-term hold candidate with solid upside. Collectors can capitalize on current profits or consider doubling down based on his strong performance. For budget-conscious collectors, his red rookie, priced between $50-$60, could potentially double in value if he secures Rookie of the Year honors (Shop on eBay).

Category 2: Players Poised for a Significant Jump

Ronald Acuña Jr. (Atlanta Braves)

Ronald Acuña Jr.’s phenomenal 40-70 season in 2023 significantly boosted his card market. Although injuries tempered initial enthusiasm, Acuña seems set to reclaim his MVP-level performance. A strong showing in the Home Run Derby could trigger a temporary spike in his card prices. With the Braves struggling this season, this might represent the best opportunity to sell his cards.

Andy Pages (Los Angeles Dodgers)

Andy Pages earning his first All-Star start would considerably boost his profile. Performing well on this stage in a premier market like Los Angeles can significantly increase his visibility and card value. Collectors holding Pages cards should be prepared for quick gains following standout moments or performances (Shop Andy Pages on eBay).

Riley Greene (Detroit Tigers)

After being an All-Star reserve last year, Riley Greene aims to start this year, reminding collectors of his significant upside. His team’s strong division position adds further potential for card value increases following an impactful All-Star performance. Currently, Greene’s Topps Chrome Autos trade around $110-$150 (Shop Riley Greene on eBay).

Javier Báez (Detroit Tigers)

Javier Báez, looking for redemption, has a chance to start another All-Star game. A standout performance in Atlanta could boost his comeback narrative and significantly impact his card prices. Current rookie autos under $100 could rapidly appreciate with a stellar performance (Shop on eBay).

Category 3: It’s Too Late

Shohei Ohtani and Aaron Judge

There's little left to significantly move card values for established superstars like Ohtani and Judge, especially in July. Despite their inevitable promotion during the All-Star events, dramatic price spikes are unlikely. The best approach is to hold steady or take advantage of any selling opportunity this period provides.

Timing the Market

Successful collecting requires anticipating pivotal moments before they occur. Trust your instincts about players poised for breakout performances during major showcases. Evaluate their current market positions, career trajectories, and potential exposure from these events. Emerging stars and small-market standouts especially benefit from these moments. Stay agile and ready; card values shift quickly as All-Star selections and performances unfold.

Which All-Star are you holding that you hope has a massive game? Let us know on Mantel.

Written by Dante Tardino