Published July 02, 2025 | By Alyx E, Founder of Collectors MD

There’s a dark undercurrent running through the hobby right now—one that too often gets dismissed as “just part of the game.” But the truth is, predatory selling tactics and misinformation are becoming normalized, and it’s harming collectors in ways we don’t talk about enough.

Breakers, sellers, and platforms are leaning hard into urgency, hype, and manipulation. They pump comps that aren’t real, cherry-pick outlier sales, and build fake value off of gimmicks like wheels, repacks, and trade-back “bonuses” that almost always leave the buyer holding the short end. It’s all framed as fun. As entertainment. As a community experience. But beneath the surface? It’s a pressure cooker.

Momentum has replaced logic. Emotion has replaced math.

People are spending more than they can afford because they’re being manipulated into thinking they’re hitting big when in reality, they’re being sold stories, not value.

Let’s talk comps. How often do you see breakers referencing eBay listings that don’t show the final sale price—just the original asking price? Tools like 130pt or CardLadder actually reveal what an offer was accepted at, but that rarely gets used. Instead, we hear hypebeasts in the chat claiming a card is “worth triple” what it actually sells for, and the breaker runs with it—telling a customer they just made a profit when they actually lost half their buy-in.

Same card. Same sale. Two totally different “comps.” Top: eBay shows the original asking price. Bottom: 130pt reveals the actual accepted offer—nearly $5,000 less. This is why misleading comps are such a problem in the hobby. If you’re not using the right tools, you could be pricing—or buying—based on fiction. Don’t fall for inflated hype. Do your homework.

And here’s the kicker—if you dare to call this out, people don’t say thank you. They attack. And quite often you’ll be banned by the host or a moderator for spreading “negativity”.

Why? Why do people defend breakers so aggressively—even in the face of misinformation?

Because in this hobby, some breakers aren’t just sellers—they’re community leaders, personalities, and emotional anchors. Challenging them doesn’t feel like feedback—it feels like betrayal. People feel personally invested in these identities, and when that gets threatened, the reaction is often tribal, defensive, and irrational.

There’s also something deeper going on—cognitive dissonance. If someone has spent thousands with a breaker and suddenly they’re told that person may be manipulating comps or misleading them? That’s a tough pill to swallow. So instead of reevaluating the situation, they double down. They justify. They protect their investment—even if it means denying the truth.

At Collectors MD, we’re not here to cancel the hobby or crucify anyone. But we are here to say: misinformation is not entertainment. Manipulation is not community. And hype that hurts people isn’t hype—it’s harm.

If we want a hobby that’s sustainable, honest, and supportive, we need to be willing to ask hard questions—even about the people we admire.

Collect With Intention. Heal With Support.

#CollectorsMD
Community shouldn’t come at the cost of clarity.

—
Follow us on Instagram: @collectorsmd
Subscribe to our Newsletter & Support Group
Join The Conversation On Mantel
Read More Daily Reflections