Published March 15, 2026 | By Alyx E, Founder of Collectors MD
For most collectors, the hobby begins with something simple. A pack at the card shop. A favorite player. A memory tied to a moment in sports history. But over time, something subtle can change. The hobby starts to feel less like collecting and more like chasing. Not because collectors suddenly lose discipline or intelligence, but because many modern systems are designed to tap into a powerful behavioral pattern.
Author Michael Easter calls this pattern the Scarcity Loop. It’s a simple three-part cycle that has been used for decades in casinos, apps, and digital platforms to keep people coming back. And whether intentionally or not, many parts of the modern hobby have begun to mirror this same loop.
Understanding the loop can change the way we perceive collecting in the modern day hobby.
The first component of the Scarcity Loop is Opportunity. There must be something of value available if the behavior works. In casinos, the opportunity is money. In social media, it’s attention and validation. In the hobby, the opportunity is the hit. The superfractor. The logoman. The 7-figure card everyone dreams about hitting.
Boxes and breaks are built around this opportunity. A collector opens a pack knowing that somewhere inside the product might be something extraordinary. That possibility is powerful. It’s also what draws many of us to the hobby in the first place.
The second component of the loop is Unpredictable Rewards. You know a reward might come, but you don’t know when. It could be the next pack. It could be the next box. It could be the next break. This unpredictability is incredibly stimulating to the brain. When rewards are random instead of guaranteed, dopamine spikes even higher. That’s why slot machines don’t pay out consistently. The randomness keeps people engaged.
Modern collecting has adopted similar mechanics. A box might contain nothing but base cards. Or it might contain a life-changing pull. Most of the time, it’s somewhere in between. A parallel. A numbered card. A near miss. And those near misses matter. They keep the brain thinking the next one might be the big one.
The third component of the loop is Quick Repeatability. The behavior has to be easy to repeat immediately. In a casino, you can spin again in seconds or play another hand. In the modern hobby, you can buy another spot in a break instantly. Another pack. Another box. Another auction bid. The loop resets faster than ever.
What starts as curiosity can slowly become repetition. The image isn’t the point – the pattern is. When the same emotional sequence keeps getting triggered over and over, the hobby can stop feeling like a choice and start feeling like momentum.
Opportunity. Unpredictable reward. Repeat. Over and over again. None of this means collecting itself is inherently the problem. The hobby has always carried an element of chance. Opening packs has always been part of the magic. But the speed, scale, and accessibility of today’s ecosystem means the Scarcity Loop can run much faster than it used to.
Live breaks run around the clock. Apps remove friction between desire and purchase.
Highlights of massive pulls flood social media feeds. The industry didn’t invent human psychology, but it has learned how to work with it. And when the loop runs unchecked, the line between entertainment and compulsion can start to blur.
Understanding the Scarcity Loop doesn’t mean you have to walk away from a hobby you’ve enjoyed since childhood. In fact, it can help you stay in it longer. Because once you recognize the pattern, you can begin to slow it down.
Maybe that means setting a budget before a break. Maybe it means buying singles instead of chasing packs. Maybe it means stepping away when the experience stops feeling fun. The goal isn’t to eliminate excitement. The goal is to keep the hobby from controlling the collector.
Collecting should still feel like joy, curiosity, and connection. Not a loop you can’t step out of.
#CollectorsMD
Understanding the loop is the first step toward breaking it.
—
Follow us on Instagram: @collectorsmd
Subscribe to our Newsletter & Support Group
Join The Conversation On Mantel
Read More Daily Reflections
