Article
Connor McDavid’s Moment: A Deep Dive Into the Booming Market for His Collectibles
Published Jun 13 2025
Connor McDavid is once again having a dominant postseason, leading the Edmonton Oilers to another Stanley Cup Final. With 32 points in 20 games, he’s at the top of NHL playoff scoring alongside teammate Leon Draisaitl. At this point, words like “superb” or “dazzling” don’t even do him justice—everything’s already been said.
In Game 1 of the Final, McDavid added to his highlight reel by setting up Leon Draisaitl for the OT winner. In Game 4, he notched another assist during a dramatic overtime comeback. Despite this, the Oilers remain in a tight battle with the defending champion Florida Panthers, and the series is currently tied at 2-2.
McDavid's Market Already Heating Up
McDavid’s cards and memorabilia have been in demand ever since he entered the league, and this year is no different. His market continues to climb, and if he ends up winning the Cup, expect even more upside. His premium-level collectibles have always been strong, but now even the mid-tier and entry-level cards are catching fire. Here are some notable pieces worth paying attention to:
2015 Upper Deck #201 Young Guns Base Rookie
Not his priciest, but definitely his most iconic rookie card. The Young Guns brand is always a go-to for collectors, and McDavid’s is near the top of that list. According to Sports Card Investor, PSA 10s have jumped 13% in the last 30 days and are now selling between $2.4K and $3.3K. It’s one of the most coveted Young Guns cards out there—and for good reason.
2015-16 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Autograph RC #190
Probably the cheapest autographed McDavid rookie—though that still means it last sold raw for $1,536. What makes this card stand out is its variety of parallels (like Traxx /125 or Rainbow Purple /15), making it a great option for set builders or collectors looking for unique options.
2015 UD Star Rookies #1 Base
This is likely the most affordable McDavid rookie card on the market. It’s recently been selling between $114–$265 (PSA 10), and in just the last month, it's seen a 57% jump. If you’re looking for an accessible entry point, this could be it—but don’t wait too long.
2015 SP Authentic Future Watch Auto #226
A fan favorite known for its eye appeal, brand strength, and investment value. This one’s not cheap—PSA 10s have been selling between $9.6K and $14.1K over the last month. Still, it's widely viewed as one of McDavid’s best autographed rookies outside of The Cup.
2015-16 Upper Deck The Cup Signed Patch Rookie #197
This is the McDavid card. High-end, ultra-rare, and visually elite. Prices have ranged from $115K–$200K in recent years. And with Goldin currently hosting an auction where one is sitting at $22K, a serious collector might be able to make a move. Long term? This could be the most valuable hockey card ever if McDavid ends his career with a full trophy case.
4-Nations Game-Worn Team Canada Jersey
This jersey, worn during the NHL 4 Nations Tournament versus the USA, carries extra significance. McDavid hasn’t played in an Olympics, making this a rare international appearance. Not only did he wear the red and white, but he also scored the OT winner in the championship game. The jersey from his first game against the US in that tournament sold for $47K—an all-time great modern memorabilia piece.
Why Now Might Be the Best Time to Buy
McDavid is already tracking to be one of the greatest players in NHL history. If he wins a Stanley Cup, his market could escalate from premium to untouchable. While his cards are already expensive, there's still room to grow. For those who believe in playing the long game, this might be the best time to buy in.
Your collection deserves a community. Download Mantel today.
