User profile picture

3041

sweetpea

Sep 23

Edited

Grading Subjectivity on a Recent Pick Up From PSA 6 to BGS 8

Sports Cards

Grading

My recent pick up highlights something that needs a better solution, the subjectivity of an individual grader. More on that later. I love this card for its patch with Lewis name and his driver number in the background. PSA graded this a 6 and regraded by BGS as a 8. The gap is big -- and makes me wonder how much of card prices tied to a grade where subjectivity is such a big factor? Is there a scenario where grading shouldn't matter in a cards value or less of an impact and the cards' scarcity/provenance or significance more important?

🔥
👍
User profile picture
User profile picture
User profile picture
Suggestions image

Join the Conversation on Mantel, a Community for Collectors!

Create an account to discover more interesting stories about collectibles, and share your own with other collectors.

Replies (6)

Loading...

Feed

Groups

Mantelpiece

Search

Profile