1993-94 Upper Deck Rookie Exchange

There was nothing like the ’93-94 Upper Deck Rookie Exchange program.

Back then, you didn’t wait months wondering if your redemption would ever show up — you mailed it in, and Upper Deck actually sent your cards back quickly. And the best part? The redemption wasn’t some flimsy throwaway piece of cardboard. It was designed like an actual ticket, and once your claim was processed, they’d punch it and return it with your rookies.

Little touches like that are why the ’90s and the so-called Junk Wax Era will always be the top dog. It wasn’t just about the cards — it was about the experience, the mail-day excitement, and a hobby that felt personal.

What’s your favorite redemption memory from the era?