It’s not often that you get two athletes, from different teams, that get their 1st Sports Illustrated cover appearance on the same issue. This is Rick Sutcliffe and Dwight Gooden and it came out today in 1984.

Sutcliffe won the Cy Young in 1984 and Dwight Gooden won it in 1985. This copy graded in newsstand at CGC 9.6 is a pop 2 with none graded higher