Thought I would go old and new school. The great Christy Mathewson since his playing day cards can be a pretty penny I have purchased several of the Topps SPs and other cards in modern era.

I’ve been looking for nice one of these for a few years. While they’re not incredibly rare, they are about 125 years old! The reason I was looking for this one in particular is because I love Jim Thorpe items. And this is, essentially, a rookie card of his. A cool card like this that has multiple Hall of Famer’s is a must-have for me. It only received an SGC 1.5, but the eye appeal is stellar. It received an excellent from PWCC placing on the top of 15% of all similar cards based on eye appeal.