Published December 04, 2025 | By Alyx E, Founder of Collectors MD
Just when it felt like we’d finally moved past gimmicky reverse Dutch auctions and FOTL-style releases, the hobby winds up and lands another unexpected haymaker.
Today, Fanatics and Topps rolled out their first “First Day Issue” reverse Dutch auction for 2025-26 Topps Chrome Basketball, starting at $3,500 a box and eventually selling out around $1,750. On paper, it’s being marketed as a “premium configuration” with exclusive parallels and early-arrival boxes. In reality, it felt like déjà vu—Panini’s “First Off The Line” all over again, just with a different logo in the corner. The Spiderman meme practically wrote itself: two companies pointing at each other, running the exact same playbook that helped warp the hobby in the first place.
What made today so jarring wasn’t just the number on the screen. It was the way so many of us instinctively moved into monitoring mode. Refreshing the page. Asking each other, “Where does it settle?” “What’s the minimum?” “When does it sell out?” We weren’t just watching a product drop—we were watching a live experiment in how far the market can be stretched before we break. And once that “final” price is established, we already know what happens next: breakers, card shops, and online resellers stacking a 50–100% markup on top of an already inflated floor, turning a four-figure wax box into a ‘new normal”.
In our group chat, you could hear the whole emotional spectrum in real time—anger, sarcasm, exhaustion, resignation. Jokes about breakers hoarding 32-box allocations. Frustration over the lack of real transparency: no public count of units sold at each tier, no usernames, no visible footprints of how the price was propped up. Because we’ve seen this movie before. Reverse Dutch auctions without transparency don’t just “discover” price; they invite manipulation. They become the perfect environment for large buyers to set artificial floors, and everyone downstream ends up paying the cost.
Seeing the interface in real time—the countdown clock, the sliding price scale, the manufactured tension—it becomes painfully clear that this isn’t just a product drop. It’s a behavioral design system built to pull you in and keep you guessing.
And even the promo makes it obvious: a glossy announcement wrapped around a format that’s anything but collector-friendly. It celebrates the release while sidestepping the tension and manipulation the model invites.
This is where the mental and emotional side of collecting gets twisted. When a release is structured like this, it stops feeling like a product and starts feeling like a gamble. You’re not just deciding whether a box is worth it—you’re deciding whether you can outguess the market before the clock runs out. That “five minutes until the next drop” timer isn’t just a feature; it’s a trigger. It taps into urgency, FOMO, and loss-chasing—the same psychological levers that drive gambling behavior. And when we normalize this style of release, we normalize those internal states too.
The hardest part is that so many of us truly love this hobby. We grew up with Chrome. We’ve built memories, friendships, and entire communities around ripping, trading, and collecting. So when companies roll out formats that feel like they’re designed to test our breaking point rather than honor our loyalty, it hits deeper than just sticker shock. It starts to erode trust. It makes intentional collectors feel like collateral damage in an endless race for “premiumization” and quarterly gains. Greed dressed up as innovation still lands as greed.
At Collectors MD, we’re not here to tell you what to buy or how to collect. But we are here to name what’s happening so you don’t have to gaslight yourself into thinking this is normal or healthy. If today’s drop left you anxious, angry, or tempted to overspend just to “get in before it’s gone”, that reaction is valid. It’s not a personal weakness; it’s a predictable response to a system designed to keep you on edge. You’re allowed to sit this one out. You’re allowed to say no. You’re allowed to opt out of formats that treat your stress as a revenue stream.
The Spiderman meme is funny, but the reality behind it isn’t. Different companies, same tactics: price gouging, manufactured scarcity, FOMO machines dressed up as “premium experiences”. The good news is that we don’t have to play along. We can choose intention over impulse, community over clout, and sanity over “getting in on the first day”. We can decide that our line in the sand isn’t dictated by a countdown timer.
#CollectorsMD
When the hobby starts to feel like a rigged game, the most powerful move you can make is to stop playing by their rules and start protecting your own.
—
Follow us on Instagram: @collectorsmd
Subscribe to our Newsletter & Support Group
Join The Conversation On Mantel
Read More Daily Reflections
