Published September 17, 2025 | By Alyx E, Founder of Collectors MD

What sells isn’t always what plays—and what plays isn’t always what holds value.

In a hobby engineered around hype and “the chase”, the market often prices narratives over performance. Like clockwork, every single season, a young, hyped starting QB is tagged with a speculation premium—regardless of the box score—or before they even step onto an NFL field. Modern day break culture amplifies it: drip-fed supply, endless highlights reels, and hope outpacing the hard data.

Meanwhile, veteran markets without a fresh storyline tend to soften—unless they’re in that rare unicorn tier—superstars, like Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen. That’s why proven starters like Dak Prescott, Jared Goff, and Matthew Stafford or even retired legends like Joe Montana, Dan Marino, and John Elway often trail young names such as Bryce Young, JJ McCarthy, and Michael Penix Jr.; the hobby consistently prices upside over past performance.

A few key takeaways to stay informed and ahead of the curve in your collecting journey:

• Youth + Starter + Hype = Liquidity.

• Narrative > Performance (until reality catches up, à la CJ Stroud, or a fresh crop of quarterbacks enter the league; Cam Ward, Jaxson Dart, etc.).

• Release cadence (Panini releasing an abundance of high end sets simultaneously) + influencer cycles (various break groups relentlessly pumping players like Trevor Lawrence) shape comps as much as if not more than on-field play.

Cards of young, unproven players selling north of $50K are the definition of speculation—superstar pricing for potential long before there’s even a résumé.

The card collecting hobby isn’t necessarily the problem; the gambling-like risk concentrates in and around break culture and prospect-chasing. Slower approaches—collecting meaningful PC pieces, set building, deliberate purchasing—are more intentional and far less volatile.

Here are a few questions to consider that can help you recalibrate as you navigate today’s fast-moving, hyper-competitive hobby landscape:

• Would I still want this card if the value was cut in half?

• Am I buying the player’s name—or the narrative I want to believe?

• Is this something I truly want and can afford—or am I just trying to keep up?

• If I couldn’t sell for a year—or five—would I be happy owning it regardless of how the player pans out?

For intentional collecting, keep these guiding principles in play:

• Pre-commit budgets and cooldowns before live streams.

• When you feel the urge to chase, choose a “no-spend action” (organize a binder, update inventory, list a card to sell, review the Collectors MD Recovery Guide, or text someone who holds you accountable) and set a 24-hour pause before any future purchase.

• Track outcomes: “hype” buys vs. “intention” buys—what actually brings you joy and satisfaction?

The bottom line: The sports card market can make absolutely no sense in the short term and still be perfectly consistent with speculation. Don’t let someone else’s hype set your compass.

Collect With Intention. Not Compulsion.

#CollectorsMD
In a hype-driven market, let intention be your edge.

—
Follow us on Instagram: @collectorsmd
Subscribe to our Newsletter & Support Group
Join The Conversation On Mantel
Read More Daily Reflections