Published November 06, 2025 | By Alyx E, Founder of Collectors MD

Once again, another live stream clip is making its rounds in the hobby—this time featuring a Whatnot seller blatantly lying about a card’s value. He claims the “last sale was $2,000” when the real comp was closer to $300. The card ultimately sells for $650—more than twice its true value—and the buyer is congratulated for “getting a steal”. But the real loss isn’t just money—it’s trust.

Moments like this reveal how far the culture of hype and manipulation has spread. What used to be about discovery and shared passion has turned into a high-speed game of deception. Platforms like Whatnot reward noise, urgency, and performance. The louder and faster you yell, the more likely you are to keep people bidding—and chasing—without ever stopping to see what’s actually happening. But when those theatrics are paired with engineered misinformation, it’s not savvy salesmanship—it’s deliberate exploitation.

The format itself fuels the problem. These “sudden-death” auctions aren’t built for informed decision-making—they’re built for reaction. Ten seconds on the clock, flashing graphics, shouting hosts, and a live chat egging you on. It’s sensory overload by design. The goal isn’t to give buyers time to think—it’s to keep them locked in emotion, chasing urgency instead of clarity.

And here’s where the deception hides: when a seller references “best offer comps” on eBay, the numbers they show aren’t always real. When an item sells via “Best Offer”, eBay’s public “sold” page only shows the original asking price, sometimes with a line through it—not the actual accepted offer.

Without hobby tools like 130 Point or Card Ladder, a buyer can’t see what an item really sold for. Some sellers know this—and weaponize it. They reference inflated eBay “last sales” that only show the asking price, not the real accepted offer—knowing very well that buyers don’t have a chance to check during a 10-second, sudden-death auction—a mechanic strategically and deceptively designed for that very reason.

On eBay, the public listing might show a card with an $800 “sold” price, when in reality, it was accepted at $500 through their “Best Offer” feature. To the untrained eye, those numbers look the same—one looks like a premium comp, the other like a realistic market value. But to a manipulative seller, that $300 gap is opportunity. It’s the difference between truth and theater—and in a high-speed, sudden-death auction, theater almost always wins.

That’s how manipulation thrives—in the split-second gap between hype and truth. And when platforms allow that behavior to go unchecked, they become complicit in it. Every dishonest comp, every false claim, every “what an absolute steal” that isn’t true chips away at the integrity of the hobby. It replaces education with exploitation and community with chaos.

If we want to rebuild the foundation of collecting, it starts with transparency. Sellers must own the responsibility to inform, not mislead. Buyers must slow down and verify—even in the chaos of high-pressure moments when the host and chat are simultaneously screaming “BID!” and “GO!”. And platforms must stop rewarding behavior that preys on impulse.

Integrity has to matter more than engagement. Truth has to matter more than sales. Because once honesty becomes optional, the hobby stops being about collecting—and starts being about control.

#CollectorsMD
Truth builds trust—and trust is the real currency of the hobby.

—
Follow us on Instagram: @collectorsmd
Subscribe to our Newsletter & Support Group
Join The Conversation On Mantel
Read More Daily Reflections