The Graded Card Collector's Home Base

A Community That Understands the Slab

Graded cards have transformed collecting from a casual hobby into a structured market, and the collectors on Mantel know every nuance. Whether you're debating PSA 10 versus BGS 9.5 Pristine, exploring the growing respect for SGC slabs on vintage, or deciding which grading company gives you the best return on your submission — this is where graded card collectors share knowledge and make better decisions.

The grading landscape spans every sport and every era. A PSA 10 Josh Allen Prizm Silver, a BGS 9.5 with a 10 auto on a Jayson Tatum National Treasures RPA, an SGC 7 on a 1933 Goudey Babe Ruth — each combination of card, grade, and grading company creates its own market. Mantel's community helps you navigate those differences with real experience and real data.

See What Collectors Are Pulling and Buying

Share your grading results and see what the community is getting back. Follow the conversations around submission turnarounds — what PSA's current timelines look like, whether BGS is grading tighter this year, and which SGC submissions are coming back with surprisingly strong grades. Graded card collectors on Mantel share pop report updates, grade distribution analysis, and the latest crossover results.

Live Marketplace Listings in One Feed

Stop filtering through raw cards when you only want slabs. Mantel pulls real-time listings from eBay and Fanatics Collect into one feed, so you can search specifically for graded cards across baseball, basketball, football, and hockey. Filter by grading company, grade, player, or set — and find the exact slab you're looking for without wading through thousands of irrelevant results.

Connect your eBay seller account to showcase your graded inventory to collectors who are specifically shopping for slabbed cards.

Comps That Tell the Real Story

Listed prices lie. Comps don't. The difference between a PSA 9 and PSA 10 can be 3x, 10x, or even 50x depending on the card — and the only way to know is what cards are actually selling for. Mantel shows you completed sales data so you can compare across grades and grading companies before making a move.

Track Price Movements Over Time

Grading company reputation, submission volumes, and population reports all shift over time, and so do the relative values of different slabs. Mantel's market trends show you how graded card prices move across days, weeks, and months. Spot when a PSA 10 premium is compressing, when BGS black label cards are gaining momentum, or when SGC vintage prices are climbing.

Go deeper with advanced analytics that measure actual trading volume and demand for specific grades. Know whether a graded card is actively trading or just sitting at stale prices.

SLAM Scores: One Number, Real Market Signal

SLAM scores combine recent sales, price trajectory, and real liquidity into one rating. For graded cards, SLAM scores help you quickly assess whether a specific grade and grading company combination has active buyer demand. Use them to compare a PSA 10 against a BGS 9.5 of the same card and see which one the market actually wants right now.

What Makes Graded Cards Unique

PSA 10 (Gem Mint) — The most recognized grade in the hobby. PSA 10s carry the strongest premiums and the deepest buyer pool. For modern cards especially, PSA 10 is the benchmark that drives pricing across the market.

BGS 9.5 Pristine and Black Labels — Beckett's half-grade system offers more granularity than PSA. A BGS 9.5 with strong subgrades can rival or exceed PSA 10 values, and BGS Black Label 10s (perfect 10 in all four subgrades) are among the rarest and most valuable slabs in existence.

SGC and the Vintage Market — SGC has earned a strong reputation among vintage collectors, with clean holder designs and consistent grading standards for older cards. SGC-graded vintage cards frequently command prices competitive with PSA, and the tuxedo slab has its own loyal following.

The Crossover Game — Many collectors buy BGS 9.5s or SGC cards at a discount and submit them to PSA hoping for a 10, capturing the premium difference. Understanding crossover success rates is a legitimate market strategy, and Mantel's community regularly discusses results.

Start Collecting Smarter

1. Join Mantel — Connect with graded card collectors who track values across PSA, BGS, SGC, and more
2. Search live listings — Browse slabbed cards from eBay and Fanatics Collect filtered by grade and grading company
3. Check comps — See what graded cards actually sold for, compared across grades and holders
4. Follow the market — Track grade premiums and SLAM scores to find the best value in slabs
5. Set alerts — Add specific graded cards to your Wish List and get notified when the right slab appears