Published November 10, 2025 | By Alyx E, Founder of Collectors MD

What we’re seeing in today’s hobby environment isn’t just speculation—it’s short-term memory loss disguised as market excitement. Every release, every “next big thing”, wipes the slate clean and resets what collectors think matters. “Value” has become a 30-day cycle, dictated by hype instead of history.

A community member in our group chat said it best while building a checklist of Chargers cards from 2010–present day—“it’s kind of scary to see how many of these guys are worth almost nothing now”. That single line says it all. We’re watching the same pattern repeat: modern cards of unproven players selling higher than legends who built the sport. How does Cam Ward outsell Joe Montana or Dan Marino? It’s the speculation gap in action—momentary emotion eclipsing long-term logic.

We’ve stopped asking the questions that used to anchor collecting:
On the monetary value front: What has this player actually accomplished? Is this card historically significant? Does it tell a story that will still matter in ten years?
On the intentional collecting front: Do I even like this player or team? Does this card mean something to me? Would I still want to own it a decade from now?

Instead, the questions have shifted to: What’s hot? Who’s next up? Which players are the most “liquid”? The algorithm doesn’t reward patience—it rewards immediacy.

Every era has its handful of “can’t-miss” athletes who somehow miss anyway—crowned before they ever took a snap or dribbled a ball, and forgotten just as fast. Hype made them stars. Time made them comps. Once a headline—now a footnote.

But the truth is, what’s hot right now rarely stays warm for long. When the hype cools, the majority of “must-have” cards fade into obscurity, just like hundreds of players who were once the “future” of a franchise. Collectors who chase the cycle eventually learn the hard way that hype has a half-life—and nostalgia doesn’t apply to things you bought out of impulse.

It’s worth remembering—we’re still talking about people. These aren’t ticker symbols or stocks to short; they’re human beings whose lives get turned into market movements. A 23-year-old quarterback has one bad game and his card prices collapse overnight. A promising rookie gets injured, and investors dump his market before he’s even had surgery. It’s a strange reality—where someone’s healing process, grief, or confidence becomes a data point for someone else’s gain. And while we tell ourselves it’s “just part of the hobby”, that kind of detachment quietly erodes empathy.

So how do we bridge the speculation gap? By collecting slower. By remembering history. By studying patterns. By asking why before how much. The hobby will always have peaks and valleys—but intention flattens the extremes. It’s not about rejecting hype, but re-framing it—seeing it for what it is rather than letting it dictate what we do.

Because hype isn’t evil—it’s just loud and chaotic. Discipline is patient and poised. And in this hobby, patience and poise usually win in the long run.

#CollectorsMD
Don’t chase the wave—study the tide.

—
Follow us on Instagram: @collectorsmd
Subscribe to our Newsletter & Support Group
Join The Conversation On Mantel
Read More Daily Reflections