In this episode of The Collector’s Compass, Alyx sits down with Dylan Genschaw, a Wisconsin-based collector and YouTube creator known for documenting new product releases, PSA submissions, and the realities of modern collecting.

Like many collectors, Dylan returned to the hobby chasing a favorite player and the excitement of opening packs. But what started as a simple search for an Aaron Rodgers card gradually evolved into spending hundreds of dollars chasing the next hit, the next rookie, and the possibility of a big return. Eventually, he stepped back, recognized how easily collecting had shifted from enjoyment to chasing outcomes, and made the decision to completely rethink his relationship with the hobby.

Today, Dylan has become a vocal advocate for intentional collecting, ending each of his videos with a reminder to "Collect with intent & spend responsibly", while encouraging viewers to learn more through Collectors MD.

In this conversation, Alyx and Dylan explore what that journey looked like firsthand—from rediscovering the hobby as an adult to recognizing unhealthy patterns before they spiraled further. They discuss the psychology behind ripping sealed product, the temptation to chase return on investment, and why so many collectors unknowingly find themselves caught in cycles driven by excitement rather than enjoyment.

The conversation also examines the growing influence of hobby content and livestream culture. Dylan shares his perspective as a creator, discussing the responsibility that comes with producing ripping content, the pressure to keep opening bigger products, and why creators have an opportunity to encourage healthier habits without taking away the fun that makes collecting special.

Finally, Alyx and Dylan discuss what intentional collecting actually looks like in practice. They talk about setting boundaries, rediscovering the joy of collecting for personal fulfillment rather than financial outcomes, and why changing hobby culture doesn't require eliminating excitement—it starts with encouraging collectors to become more thoughtful about how they participate.

At its core, this episode is about self-awareness, balance, and proving that you can love the hobby while still protecting yourself from the behaviors that can quietly turn collecting into something much different.

If you've ever found yourself chasing the next release, buying boxes you never planned on purchasing, or wondering where the line exists between collecting and chasing, this is a conversation worth listening to. Because the goal isn't to stop collecting. It's to collect with intention.

Subscribe, share, and join the conversation around healthier collecting, hobby culture, and responsible engagement.

Watch The Episode On YouTube

Learn More & Join The Movement:

Website: collectorsmd.com

Nonprofit: lohas.org/client/the-cmd-foundation

Socials: bio.collectorsmd.com

Weekly Meetings: bit.ly/45koiMX

Contact: info@collectorsmd.com

YT: ‪@collectorsmd

IG: @collectorsmd

Follow Dylan Genschaw:

YT: @dylangenschaw⁩

IG: @dylangenschaw

X: @dylangenschaw

Shop Dylan's Collection: mercari.com/u/dgen42/?sv=0

Help for Problem Gambling: Call or Text 800-GAMBLER

This Episode of The Collector's Compass is sponsored by ‪All Touch Case, a premium display and protection solution designed to showcase your cards while keeping them safe. Use code COLLECTORSMD for 15% of your order. Collect. Protect. It’s a peace of mind.

#CollectorsMD | #TheCMDFoundation | #RipResponsibly

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uRp6FqF58AE&t=5568s

Presented By All Touch Case

Since launching our Collector Spotlight series, a handful of our community members have asked me the same question: “When are you going to do a Collector Spotlight on your own collection?”

I’ve honestly been putting this one off. I’ve never wanted Collectors MD to be about me. But after enough people asked, I figured it was time to share a little more about my own collecting journey – and why this organization means so much to me.

Like so many collectors, my story began in childhood. Whether it was trading cards, sneakers, jerseys, signed memorabilia, or anything connected to the teams and athletes I admired growing up, collecting quickly became much more than a hobby. It became a way to preserve memories, celebrate milestones, and stay connected to the sports, people, and moments that shaped my life.

Over time, however, what started as passion gradually became accumulation – and eventually, obsession. At one point, I owned more than 550 pairs of sneakers, thousands of trading cards, hundreds of hats, jerseys, luxury watches, signed memorabilia, and countless other collectibles spread throughout my home. From the outside, it probably looked like the dream collection many hobbyists aspire to build.

But eventually, it became overwhelming. Instead of appreciating what I already owned, I found myself constantly thinking about what was next. There was always another release, another grail, another auction, another box to open, another card to chase. As my collection grew, it became increasingly difficult to enjoy the individual pieces because they were buried beneath the sheer volume of everything else.

That realization ultimately became one of the driving forces behind Collectors MD. Today, I still consider myself an active collector, but my philosophy has changed dramatically. Rather than asking myself, “What should I buy next?” I now ask, “What deserves a place in my collection?”

My collection today is significantly smaller, but far more intentional. Every piece has earned its place because it tells a story. My signed Eli Manning jersey takes me back to a core memory – watching one of the greatest upsets in Super Bowl history with my father during my high school years. My Derek Jeter autograph captures my lifelong love for the Yankees and one of the athletes I admired most growing up. My Jalen Brunson cards reflects the resurgence of Knicks basketball and, after decades of waiting, finally bringing a championship back to New York. My sneaker collection represents different chapters of my life. Other pieces simply remind me of people I’ve met, places I’ve been, or moments I’ll never forget.

Ironically, many of the items I value most aren’t by any means the most expensive. Their value comes from the memories they represent. That’s what intentional collecting means to me today – not collecting more, but collecting with purpose.

It’s also important to recognize that intentional collecting looks different for everyone. For some collectors, a room filled wall-to-wall with thousands of cards or hundreds of sneakers is exactly what brings them joy. If someone has the financial means, the available space, the time, and the emotional bandwidth to maintain a large collection while keeping it a positive part of their life, there’s absolutely nothing wrong with that.

Intentional collecting isn’t about owning less. It’s about owning in a way that aligns with your life, your priorities, and your well-being. For me, that meant significantly downsizing until every piece left in my collection truly felt meaningful. For someone else, it may mean continuing to build an expansive collection they genuinely enjoy. Neither approach is inherently right or wrong.

What matters is that your collection serves you – not the other way around. At Collectors MD, we often say there is no universal definition of a “healthy collection”. Some collectors are perfectly content owning twenty cards. Others find meaningful fulfillment in owning twenty thousand cards. The goal isn’t to fit into someone else’s definition of collecting. The goal is to build a collection that enhances your life instead of consuming it.

If there’s one thing I’ve learned throughout my own journey, it’s that the most meaningful collections aren’t always measured by size or market value. They’re measured by the stories they tell, the memories they preserve, and the joy they continue to bring long after the excitement of acquiring them has faded.

Sometimes the greatest collection isn’t the one with the most pieces. It’s the one where every piece still means something.

Below is a glimpse into a few of the pieces that continue to mean the most to me.

#CollectorsMD
Collect With Intention. Not Compulsion.

This Collector Spotlight is sponsored by All Touch Case, a premium display and protection solution designed to showcase your cards while keeping them safe. Use code COLLECTORSMD for 15% off your order. Collect. Protect. It’s a peace of mind.

https://collectorsmd.com/collector-spotlight-june-2026/

The hobby doesn’t look the same for everyone. Some people need better data. Some need more structure. Some need better tools. Some just need a healthier way to engage.

That’s exactly why we created The Intentional Collector’s Guide by Collectors MD - a one-stop resource designed to help collectors navigate the the modern-day hobby with more clarity, awareness, and intention.

Inside, we’ve highlighted a curated mix of hobby-related tools, platforms, products, and resources from trusted strategic partners across the space - all built to help you tailor your hobby journey to your collecting profile.

Whether you’re looking for:

• Better market data

• Smarter collection management

• Safer shipping / protection

• Grading / prep tools

• Or a more grounded way to engage with the hobby

…this guide was built for you.

The goal isn’t to approach the hobby exactly like everyone else. It’s to build a version of it that actually works for you. And at the center of it all is #RipResponsibly - a reminder that collecting should add value to your life, not take away from it.

Check out The Intentional Collector’s Guide now live on our newly refreshed website.

#CollectorsMD | #RipResponsibly | #CollectResponsibly

This month, we’re proud to feature Conor McGrath—one of our own team members and a collector whose story is deeply rooted in Boston sports, 90s basketball, and the moments that stay with you long after the game ends.

Conor’s collection is built on more than players and cardboard. It’s tied to identity, memory, and the emotional imprint that sports can leave behind. Growing up just outside of Boston, sports weren’t just part of the culture—they were the culture. The teams, the heartbreak, the history, and the expectations were always there.

And in the 1990s, there was plenty of heartbreak to go around. For Boston fans, it was a difficult era. The Celtics were rebuilding and still reeling from devastating losses. The Red Sox couldn’t quite get over the hump. The Patriots were a long way from becoming the dynasty people now associate with New England sports. It was a frustrating stretch for the city—but like so many kids growing up during that time, Conor found something bigger through basketball.

That’s where the connection really took hold. Like many collectors of that era, he was drawn in by the stars who felt larger than life. Jordan. Shaq. The rise of 90s basketball. The visual energy of the hobby itself. Cards like Beam Team didn’t just stand out—they stuck. And from there, the collection kept growing.

As the decade moved forward, so did the players who shaped his PC. The legendary draft classes from 1996 through 1998 left a huge imprint on Conor’s collecting identity. Kobe Bryant, Allen Iverson, Ray Allen, Tim Duncan, Vince Carter, Dirk Nowitzki, Paul Pierce—so many of the players who defined that era still anchor his collection today. That stretch of basketball helped shape not just what he collected, but why he connected to it in the first place.

But according to Conor, the most meaningful item in his collection isn’t a card at all. It’s a jacket. A black and yellow Boston Marathon volunteer jacket from 2013—his first year volunteering at the race, and a year the city will never forget. The events of that day left a lasting impact, but what stayed with him just as deeply was what came after: the resilience, unity, and compassion that poured out of Boston and the broader running community in response. That spirit carried into sports in a way that felt impossible to ignore.

When the Red Sox won the 2013 World Series, it wasn’t just another championship. To Conor, it felt like something more. Bigger, even, than 2004. It felt like a city reclaiming itself. A reminder of what people can do when they come together after pain, and a moment that captured Boston’s grit, heart, and resilience in real time. That’s what the jacket represents.

Today, Conor’s collection tells a layered story—one about growing up around Boston sports, falling in love with 90s basketball, and holding onto the moments that meant something deeper than the scoreboard. It’s a reminder that collecting isn’t just about what you own. It’s about what it represents, and the memories it helps you carry forward.

Conor leaves us with a reminder that feels especially fitting: the most meaningful pieces in a collection aren’t always the rarest or most valuable. Sometimes they’re the ones that hold the most story.

#CollectorsMD
Collect With Intention. Not Compulsion.

https://collectorsmd.com/collector-spotlight-march-2026/

Published March 22, 2026 | By Alyx E, Founder of Collectors MD

There’s a version of collecting that feels like progress. A constant state of motion – packs, boxes, breaks, auctions, listings, packages, notifications, screenshots, new releases, bigger cards, better hits. Enough noise and activity to convince ourselves something meaningful is taking shape. But movement without direction is just motion, and accumulation without intention is just excess.

For a long time, I told myself I was participating in something I was passionate about. That I was evolving as a collector. That I was getting sharper, more strategic, more legitimate. At one point, I even convinced myself it was a profitable side hustle. When I reflect back now, it’s clear – it wasn’t progress I was making – it was momentum without direction – an unpredictable violent storm. And that kind of force never pauses to ask where it’s headed – it just barrels through everything in its path.

Over time, my iCloud became the archive of that momentum. 381,722. That’s the total number of photos, screenshots, videos, and screen recordings currently sitting in my photos app. And the majority of them are hobby-related – screenshots from personal rips, hits from breaks, purchased lots and singles – cards I thought would matter, material items I convinced myself I needed. In the moment those items felt like they meant something. That six-figure number is hard to process – and even harder to accept.

It’s easy to mistake motion for meaning. When everything is moving fast, it feels like something important must be happening. But speed has a way of hiding intention. And if we never stop to ask where we’re going, we can spend years going absolutely nowhere.

When I scroll through those endless photos today, one thing becomes impossible to ignore – I no longer own the vast majority of those cards. They were never meaningful enough to keep long term. They were just part of a cycle. And most of what did matter, I eventually ended up having to sell to offset numerous losses. What’s left behind today isn’t an impressive collection or some massive financial return. It’s a trail – a digital record of years spent chasing something I couldn’t fully define at the time.

I was never actually building a collection. I was simply maintaining momentum. Chasing the next release, trying to keep up, reaching for a feeling that kept slipping away. And the moments that reinforced the cycle the most weren’t the losses – they were the wins. The most dangerous outcome isn’t necessarily losing. It’s convincing ourselves that the system is working. That hit that makes everything feel justified. That one card that convinces us that we’re on the right path. That brief spike of validation that resets the cycle all over again.

But even more dangerous than winning is almost winning. Because most of the damage doesn’t occur when we lose outright. It happens in the space between close and enough. When we land the right team in the break – but still get skunked. When we hit the coveted case hit – but of the wrong player. When we pull what we think will be a life-changing card, only to realize after the fact that it’s damaged. The near misses keep the cycle perpetuating and convince us to keep going, until the line between collecting and consumption disappears completely.

There comes a point where we’re no longer participating – we’re just reacting. To drops, to hype, to availability, to urgency, to everyone else around us. A collector curates with intention. A consumer reacts on impulse. And the modern hobby makes it incredibly easy to confuse the two.

Across social media, the noise can become overwhelmingly deafening. Big hits, big energy, big reactions, big moments. But what many don’t see is what happens after. The silence. The comedown. The sorting. The listing. The rationalizing. The point in time where the excitement fades and it’s no longer fun. Where we’re left in our own thoughts with what we just did. Where we realize we have nothing to show for our efforts. The hobby is presented as loud and vibrant on the surface – but behind the scenes, it can feel entirely different.

I’ve gone back through some of those photos and started deleting them – not all of them, that would take forever – but enough to realize what they really represent. And I no longer resent or regret them in the ways I used to. I see them for what they are: hard evidence; of who I was, and more importantly, of what I’ve become.

There’s a difference between holding onto proof of the past and being controlled by it. When we can look back clearly, without needing to return, that’s where real change begins to take shape.

Today, the difference is crystal clear. At the height of my addiction, my life was disassembled chaos – an ever-perpetuating cycle of directionless momentum. Through recovery, I’ve built a foundation grounded in intention, clarity, and structure. My approach is now curated, calculated, and thoughtful – which ultimately means fewer cards, more meaning, less noise, more control. And with that, a fundamentally different relationship with the hobby.

Collecting isn’t supposed to feel like something we have to keep up with just to enjoy. It’s not supposed to outpace us, or feel like progress just because it’s constant. Real progress is subtle – and often quiet. It’s intentional, selective, sustainable, and it doesn’t vanish the moment we slow down.

If we step back and look at what we’ve built, we should be able to see something we’re truly proud of – not just fleeting moments or endless chasing, but something real. And if we can’t see it, that might be our signal to pause and reconnect – with intention.

#CollectorsMD
Are we really making progress if we don’t know where we’re headed?

—
Follow us on Instagram: @collectorsmd
Subscribe to our Newsletter & Support Group
Join The Conversation On Mantel
Read More Daily Reflections