Looking for value on this

Published August 12, 2025 | By Alyx E, Founder of Collectors MD

Each year, we expect a slight fluctuation in prices across industries—it’s part of market trends: inflation, supply and demand, and the natural ebb and flow of production costs.

But in the hobby, the bar keeps moving, drastically—and not in the right direction. Today, 2025 Topps Finest Baseball hit shelves at an eye-watering $500 per hobby box. Let’s rewind: last year's 2024 release sold for $300 a box—with a better rookie class and arguably a better design. In 2023, they were $225 a box.

This isn't just a one-off. It's the same exact story across the board. And it’s not just a price increase—it’s a pattern. Year-over-year, across almost every product line, we’re watching manufacturers, platforms, and breakers push prices higher under the same tired excuse: "That’s just the market."

Topps Finest 2025 – $499.95 on release day. That’s a 67% markup from last year’s $300, and a 122% jump from $225 just two years ago—for an inferior rookie class and a lazier design. This isn’t market “adjustment.” It’s exploitation.

2025 Topps Chrome Baseball just dropped a few weeks back and "Breaker's Delight" boxes were closing in on $700 right out the gate. Last year they were $450 a pop and the year before they were $330. The naming convention couldn’t be more fitting—this is certainly a delight for the breakers, but the customers? Not so much.

Frankly, the markups are insulting. Manufacturers, platforms, and breakers are exploiting the reality that people will rip the product no matter the price—fueling the addictive behaviors we constantly reference and amplifying them with a manufactured sense of urgency. It all feels deceptively calculated.

So who's to blame in all of this?

Now, we understand supply and demand—but what are we actually doing here? These extreme price hikes are singlehandedly chipping away at the integrity of the hobby. And this isn’t even touching the deeper issues at play—this is just the surface.

The problem starts with the manufacturers, the key decision-makers steering the hobby.

Here’s the kicker—it’d be one thing if manufacturers were introducing innovative tech or game-changing features to justify these price jumps. But we don’t even see increases like this with new car models year over year. Instead, they’re raising prices for one simple reason: because they can.

Their mindset? Most boxes today move through multi-box breaks, so the per-team price hike feels "marginal" to the buyer. The sticker shock gets buried behind a randomized spot in a break, making the price increase far less noticeable—by design.

It’s subtle. It’s strategic. And it’s deceptive.

Year after year, the prices climb higher—while collectors are left hanging on for dear life.

But at the end of the day, we’re not dumb. The numbers don’t lie—and neither does the growing frustration among collectors. These extreme price hikes don’t just drain wallets—they erode trust. They undermine the foundation the hobby is built on. Because if the cost of entry keeps climbing at this pace, collecting stops being about passion and personal connection—and becomes solely about who can afford to stay in the game.

While this is only one piece of a much bigger problem, it’s one of the clearest indicators of where things are headed. These price jumps are driven from the top—the manufacturers, the platforms, and the executives making the calls. If this continues without oversight or accountability, it’s the kind of greed that doesn’t just strain collectors—it risks undermining the entire hobby.

The hobby can’t thrive on adrenaline alone. It needs accessibility, balance, and a fair shot for everyone—not just those willing to pay whatever the market will bear.

#CollectorsMD
If we don’t call out the deception now, it’ll cement itself as the norm—and once that happens, it’s here to stay.

—
Follow us on Instagram: @collectorsmd
Subscribe to our Newsletter & Support Group
Join The Conversation On Mantel
Read More Daily Reflections