257
257
Eagles33
Chad Brayman
11
Posts
0
Topics
9
Followers
9
Following
11
Posts
0
Topics
9
Followers
9
Following
Invite Friends & Earn Rewards
Work your way up to exclusive Mantel rewards by inviting your friends.

Mantel Points
257
Bio
Lifelong collector turned vinyl-focused in 2020. When I couldn’t find a way to grade records, we built Vintage Media Grading—designed for collectors, with integrity at the core.
Kentucky Derby Triple Crown Ticket Stubs
+7
This lineup features original Kentucky Derby ticket stubs from every Triple Crown winner — with one special exception. While I don’t yet have the 1919 stub from Sir Barton’s historic run, I’ve included a rare 1920 Sir Barton vs. Man o’ War match race ticket as a unique placeholder. All other stubs are originals from the horses’ respective Derby wins. Journalism seems to have a chance to crack this list.
1919 – Sir Barton: The first Triple Crown winner. Using a 1920 Sir Barton vs. Man o’ War match race ticket in place of the Derby stub.
1930 – Gallant Fox: Only Triple Crown winner to sire another (Omaha).
1935 – Omaha: The second Crown winner — and the only one bred in the U.S. but raced overseas.
1937 – War Admiral: Son of Man o’ War and a fierce competitor, despite smaller stature.
1941 – Whirlaway: Known for his erratic running and blazing speed — the “Flying Tail.”
1943 – Count Fleet: Dominated the Belmont by 25 lengths, a record until Secretariat.
1946 – Assault: Overcame a physical disability to become one of racing’s most unlikely champions.
1948 – Citation: First horse to earn over $1 million and a true post-war superstar.
1973 – Secretariat: Set records in all three Triple Crown races — still unmatched today.
1977 – Seattle Slew: First horse to win the Triple Crown while undefeated.
1978 – Affirmed: Triumphed over rival Alydar in three thrilling photo finishes.
2015 – American Pharoah: Ended a 37-year drought and went on to win the Breeders’ Cup Classic — the only horse ever to claim the Grand Slam. Breeders’ Cup ticket included.
2018 – Justify: Only horse to win the Triple Crown without racing as a 2-year-old — retired undefeated.
Wrestling & MMA Rookies
+5
These were really fun to discover and collect. There was a time when wrestling cards were very inexpensive — those days are long gone.
The Andre Yamakatsu card was one of my favorites. It took nearly two years to finally get that card approved for grading at PSA. I never found one, but the Andre card with the “Winner” stamp is my favorite choice for his best rookie card.
The Hulk Hogan Popy card is also very limited and a great card, in my opinion.
Does anyone have more information on the Liddell card? I was able to date it because his age was listed on the back, but I was never able to gather enough information for PSA to start grading it.
UFC / MMA
Bruce Lee 1974 Yamakatsu Way of the Dragon
The legend. The icon. Bruce Lee’s rare 1974 Yamakatsu card ties martial arts and pop culture into one historic piece.Chuck Norris 1974 Yamakatsu Way of the Dragon Series 2
Before the memes, Chuck Norris was the tough guy — and this 1974 Yamakatsu card captures him at the height of his martial arts fame.Ken Shamrock 1995 BBM
The “World’s Most Dangerous Man” hits cardboard in this early BBM release, just as he transitioned from pro wrestling to UFC stardom.Randy Couture 1998 Culture House - Asics Heroes of Wrestling
Long before becoming a UFC icon, Randy Couture appeared in this U.S.-produced Culture House set honoring amateur wrestling legends.Chuck Liddell 2003 Sherdog
The Iceman’s first card, included as a bonus with Sherdog’s DVD or VHS releases — a tough find that captures Liddell right before his UFC superstardom.Royce Gracie 2006 Pride Card Collection
The man who dominated the early UFC scene shows up here in the Pride FC set, representing pure jiu-jitsu greatness.
Real Wrestling
Frank Gotch 1909 Ogden’s
One of the earliest wrestling legends on cardboard — Frank Gotch’s 1909 Ogden’s is a true piece of sports history.Daniel Gable 1972 Panini Munich
Dan Gable’s Olympic gold captured by Panini, just before he went on to reshape American wrestling forever.
Wrestling (80s Heavy since that’s when I mostly watched wrestling)
Andre The Giant 1974 Yamakatsu New Japan Pro Wrestling
Andre’s first true card from his early dominance in Japan — before he became a worldwide phenomenon.Ric Flair 1982 Wrestling All-Stars Series A
“Woooo!” The Nature Boy’s cardboard debut in the iconic Wrestling All-Stars set that kicked off the wrestling card boom.Hulk Hogan 1981 Popy
Before Hulkamania, Hogan’s first appearance came via this Japanese Popy figure card — a true grail for wrestling collectors.Hulk Hogan 1982 Wrestling All-Stars
The definitive early Hulk Hogan card from the Wrestling All-Stars set that changed wrestling collectibles forever.Mr. T 1983 The A-Team Topps
Pity the fool who doesn’t recognize Mr. T’s cultural crossover power — immortalized in the A-Team card set.The Road Warriors 1985 Wrestling All Stars
No tag team hit harder or looked cooler — The Road Warriors’ early card is as intense as their in-ring legacy.Randy Savage 1985 O-Pee-Chee Series 2
“Ooooh yeah!” Macho Man’s Canadian O-Pee-Chee rookie is one of wrestling’s most colorful and iconic cards.The British Bulldogs 1985 O-Pee-Chee Series 2
Davey Boy Smith and Dynamite Kid show up in this early O-Pee-Chee release, just as they were redefining tag team wrestling.Roddy Piper 1985 O-Pee-Chee WWF Pro Wrestling Stars
The Hot Rod’s fiery persona is captured perfectly in his first mainstream card from the classic O-Pee-Chee WWF set.Bret Hart 1987 O-Pee-Chee WWF Pro Wrestling Stars
The Hitman’s first solo cardboard appearance — and a must for any fan of excellence.Sting 1987 Wonderama Test
Before the face paint and black baseball bats, young Sting got his start with this rare Wonderama test issue.Ultimate Warrior 1989 WWF Super Stars Of Wrestling Series 3
Feel the power! Warrior’s explosive first mainstream card captures his larger-than-life energy.Demolition 1989 WWF Super Stars Of Wrestling Series 1
Axes and smash hits — Demolition’s early WWF card brings the heavy metal vibe to your collection.Steve Austin 1991 Cromy
Before Stone Cold — Stunning Steve Austin appears on this rare South American Cromy issue. A cold start to a red-hot career.The Rockers (Shawn Michaels) 1989 WWF Super Stars Of Wrestling Series 1
Before HBK became the Showstopper, Shawn Michaels debuted as part of The Rockers — fresh-faced and ready to fly.John Cena 2002 Fleer Royal Rumble
The Champ’s cardboard beginnings — John Cena’s first appearance in a WWE set, just as he was getting ready to rise to the top.The Rock 1994 Miami Hurricanes
Before laying the smackdown, Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson was chasing football dreams — captured here in his rare Miami Hurricanes card.
Presidential Inaguration Ticket Stubs
+1
I wanted to start a collection with real historical significance, and I decided on presidential inauguration ticket stubs. I’m not sure exactly how far back inauguration tickets exist—I’ve never seen anything earlier than Lincoln, so targeting Lincoln to present.. Since McKinley, I’m only missing one. The 1921 Warren Harding tickets seem especially rare; I haven’t seen one come up for sale yet. Since Gerald Ford never had an inauguration, I’m using a national convention ticket to represent him. One thing that bothers me is how PSA slabbed a few of the tickets in different directions, but I’ll eventually have that corrected. Most tickets from the 1900s to today are relatively affordable, but the ones from the 1800s can start to get expensive.
2021 U.S. President Inauguration-Full Full Joe Biden January 20 - Amethyst
2017 U.S. President Inauguration-Full Full Donald Trump January 20-Red
2009 U.S. President Inauguration-Full Full Barack Obama January 20-Blue
2001 U.S. President Inauguration-Pass Pass George W. Bush January 20
1993 U.S. President Inauguration-Pass Pass Bill Clinton January 20-North Standing
1981 U.S. President Inauguration- Full Ronald Reagan January 20 - President Platform
1989 U.S. President Inauguration-Pass Pass George Bush January 20- Gold
1977 U.S. President Inauguration-Full Full James E. Carter January 20-Southeast Front Capitol
1976 Republican National Convention-Full Aug.19,Kansas City/Gerald Ford Session 5
1969 U.S. President Inauguration-Full Richard M. Nixon January 20
1965 U.S. President Inauguration- Stub Lyndon B. Johnson January 20
1961 U.S. President Inauguration- Stub John F. Kennedy January 20
1953 U.S. President Inauguration- Stub Dwight D. Eisenhower Inauguration-January 20
1949 U.S. President Inauguration- Stub Harry S. Truman Inauguration-January 20
1933 U.S. President Inauguration- Stub Franklin D. Roosevelt Inauguration-January 20
1929 U.S. President Inauguration-Pass Herbert C. Hoover March 4
1925 U.S. President Inauguration- Pass Calvin Coolidge March 4
1913 U.S. President Inauguration- Pass Woodrow Wilson March 4
1908 U.S. President Inauguration- Pass William Taft March 4
1908 U.S. President Inauguration- Pass Theodore Roosevelt March 4
1897 U.S. President Inauguration- Pass William McKinley March 4
1877 U.S. President Inauguration- Pass Rutherford B Hayes March 5
1869 U.S. President Inauguration- Pass Ulysses S Grant March 4
1868 U.S. President Impeachment Trial - Pass Andrew Johnson May 7
Up Next We’re My Soccer Rookies
These cards exploded in price more than any other sport. I had the most “sellers remorse” with these. It was fun discovering these sets and working with PSA to get them approved for grading. Worked with PSA to get the following sets approved for grading: 1978 Figurita Crack Mundial, 2002 Panini Mega Craques, 2009 Gol Cards. Especially notable that the Ronaldo card later appeared on the cover of SMR Magazine, years after we first got the set approved.
Soccer Rookie Cards
Pelé – 1958 Ave Ltda. Coleção Titulares
One of several Pelé cards from 1958, chosen for being made in Brazil. PSA labeled these as hand-cut. A few 1957 issues have surfaced since, including the 1957 A Americana Ltda Balas Futebol and 1957 Oliveira & Benassi Balas Equipe.
Franz Beckenbauer – 1965 Perfetti Candy
Early Italian-issued card of the German great, distributed with Perfetti candy products.
George Best – 1964 Barratt & Co. Ltd Famous Footballers
UK-issued rookie of the Manchester United icon.
Diego Maradona – 1978 Figurita Crack Mundial
Early Argentine release from before Maradona’s professional debut.
Landon Donovan – 2002–03 Panini Stickers Football 2003 (#222)
International Panini sticker featuring the U.S. star in national team gear. The set was recalled shortly after release due to licensing issues, adding to its scarcity.
Roberto Baggio – 1985 Panini Calciatori
First appearance in Panini’s flagship Italian domestic set.
David Beckham – 1995 Raven Manchester Utd. Red Devils
Team-issued release predating Beckham’s mainstream Panini cards.
Cristiano Ronaldo – 2002 Panini Mega Craques
Portuguese domestic release and widely accepted Ronaldo rookie.
Lionel Messi – 2004 Panini Megacracks iconic rookie card released in Spain.
Neymar – 2009 Gol Cards
Brazilian release prior to Neymar’s move to Europe.
Kylian Mbappé – 2016 Panini Foot #505
First licensed card of Mbappé, issued during his time at AS Monaco.
Tennis Rookies
Next up is Tennis. These cards were very inexpensive pre covid. Many foreign issues emerged over time. I worked with PSA to get some of these sets slabbed for the first time.
TENNIS ROOKIE CARDS
Rene Lacoste – 1926 Lambert & Butler
First tennis card of the French legend and founder of the Lacoste brand.
Fred Perry – 1930 Cloetta
Early European card of the 3-time Wimbledon champ and fashion icon.
Arthur Ashe – 1966 Ruiz Romero Fútbol Tenis Ciclismo
Spanish multi-sport issue featuring the trailblazing Grand Slam champion.
Björn Borg – 1974 Panini Sport Vedettes
European release predating most of his Grand Slam dominance.
Jimmy Connors – 1980 Deportistas Argentinos
Long considered his first card until a 1976 Americana München #203 was discovered, now recognized as the true rookie.
John McEnroe – 1980 Deportistas Argentinos
Argentine release capturing the young American star early in his career.
Andre Agassi – 1987 Panini
Pre-professional appearance of the Las Vegas prodigy.
Pete Sampras – 1991 NetPro
First licensed U.S. card of the 14-time Grand Slam champion.
Andy Roddick – 2001 NetPro
Released just before his U.S. Open win in 2003; key early-2000s card.
Roger Federer – 2003 Czech Stadion
Often overlooked Czech card released before NetPro; Early, rare Federer card.
Rafael Nadal – 2003 NetPro
Released ahead of his Grand Slam breakout; cornerstone of modern tennis rookies.