Macklin Celebrini Cards: Collect the 2024 First Overall Pick

The Case for Getting In Early

The 2024-25 rookie hockey card market has one name that keeps surfacing at the top of every collector conversation: Macklin Celebrini. First overall picks carry built-in collector interest, but Celebrini's trajectory — a Hobey Baker Award as a freshman at Boston University, immediate NHL impact with the San Jose Sharks, and a Calder Trophy finalist campaign — puts him in rare company among recent top selections. His two-way game, compete level, and scoring instincts drew comparisons to Jonathan Toews and Patrice Bergeron, but with a higher offensive ceiling.

Sharks fans starving for a franchise cornerstone are buying aggressively. Prospectors who specialize in first overall picks view his cards as a reliable play based on the historical hit rate of top selections. The combination of draft pedigree, immediate NHL impact, and a rebuilding franchise narrative makes Celebrini one of the most collected rookies in the 2024-25 hockey card market, and the window to buy at prospect-tier pricing is closing as his production validates the hype.

Key Cards at Every Price Point

2024-25 Upper Deck Young Guns — The definitive Celebrini rookie card and the one that will anchor his long-term market. Young Guns is the most recognized rookie card brand in hockey, and the first overall pick's version always carries a premium. Expect heavy grading volume and a competitive PSA 10 market.

2024-25 SP Authentic Future Watch Auto — The premier autographed rookie in hockey. On-card signatures with limited numbering make Future Watch the card that serious collectors chase. Celebrini's version will be the most valuable auto in the 2024-25 product cycle alongside Connor Bedard holdovers.

2024-25 The Cup Rookie Patch Auto — The top-tier offering for Celebrini, numbered to 99 or less with premium patch windows. Cup RPAs from first overall picks historically hold value well and serve as the centerpiece of any high-end PC. This is where five-figure prices start.

What to Watch For — and When to Buy

First overall pick status provides a base price that holds, insulating Celebrini from the downside risk most rookies face. Beyond that, Calder Trophy contention is the near-term catalyst — winning Rookie of the Year would validate the hype and trigger a market-wide repricing of his cards. Buy before the Calder voting narrative heats up, not after. The Sharks' rebuild timeline matters too; as San Jose improves, Celebrini's role as the franchise centerpiece becomes more compelling to collectors, so shopping during a Sharks losing streak or the offseason gives you the best deals.

Pre-rookie products from his draft year are still circulating, but the market is consolidating around NHL-licensed Upper Deck releases. Watch population reports on graded Young Guns copies — they are becoming the key supply metric as more cards enter the pipeline. Early grading results and the ratio of PSA 10s to 9s will determine how aggressively the high-end tier is priced, and a batch of new PSA 10 results can briefly create a buying window before demand absorbs the added supply.

Mantel Tracks It All

First overall picks carry built-in demand, and when a breakout game or Calder Trophy moment hits, Celebrini's best cards will move fast — Mantel's Wish List alerts catch listings at your target price before the broader market reprices. Set your targets on Young Guns PSA 10s, Future Watch Autos, or any specific Celebrini card, and you will get notified the moment one surfaces at the price you want. SLAM scores measure actual sales velocity, price trends, and trading activity, so you can tell whether a strong stretch in San Jose is generating real buying pressure or temporary hype. Comps show what Celebrini cards are actually selling for — not just asking prices — giving you the transaction data to buy with confidence. Real-time listings from eBay and Fanatics Collect flow into one searchable feed, letting you compare across sellers and products without bouncing between marketplaces. And the Mantel community is where Celebrini collectors track the Sharks rebuild together, sharing rookie pickups, weighing in on the Calder race, and discussing how early grading results on Young Guns submissions are shaping the premium market.

The window to buy on a first overall pick is before the breakout performance that reprices everything overnight. Mantel gives you Wish List alerts, real-time data, and a network of collectors building their Celebrini PCs alongside you. Start tracking Celebrini cards on Mantel and get in before the market catches up.