Keep going back and forth on whether to submit this card for grading. I see encased cards listed but not many that are graded. Any experience with submitting encased cards??? Interested in any (constructive) feedback.

I’m still kind of new to the hobby, been collecting for less than a year, and I have all these cards plus some that I want to send it for grading. Some to resell and some to keep for the PC. I was thinking for PC ones using a cheaper grading service like TAG or Degree and for the ones I plan to sell spending the money for PSA. Is that a pretty solid plan? And if I decide to sell the ones in my PC down the road would you buy something graded by TAG or Degree or would I need to then crack it and submit to PSA before selling? Tell me your thoughts below!

** NOT A PUFF PIECE** TLDR 😉

Let’s play a game.

One grading company gives you:

✅ AI-powered scans

✅ 2-3 sets of human eyes

✅ Free subgrades

✅ A full digital report

✅ A slab that actually looks good

✅ And your card back in under 28 days.

Sounds amazing, right?

Well, that company is Arena Club.

And most collectors still respond with:

“Eh… does PSA take Klarna?”

“Arena Club gives the hobby what it needs… but not what it wants.”

— Someone who just got a tough 9.0 and cried into a one-touch.

Arena Club offers AI-powered grading, subgrades, and fast turnarounds—yet collectors still worship PSA. Is it the label, the hype, or are we just scared of a real grade?

Let’s be honest: Arena Club grades tough. Their 10s aren’t giveaways—they’re earned. Which is why most flippers avoid them like a redemption card from 2020.

Meanwhile, over at PSA:

• No subgrades

• No transparency

• No clue why your card got a 6

• But hey! That label is red and white and everyone on YouTube has one, so it must be good.

Oh—and PSA slabs?

Let’s just say they’ve got the same visual appeal as a DMV receipt.

Arena Club, CGC, BGS, even TAG? They all look better. It’s not even close.

🤖 But Wait—Where’s Beckett?

Remember BGS? The slab with the legendary Black Label?

It used to mean something. Now it’s collecting dust on showcase tables across the country.

You can also grab a BGS slab, with subgrades and a 28 day TAT for $35. Still better than PSA!

Collectors forgot about Beckett…

But Fanatics didn’t. 👀

If the rumors are true, Fanatics may scoop up BGS—and if they do, PSA might finally have a real competitor. Beckett still has the brand power. Fanatics has the ammo. Together? That’s a problem PSA can’t ignore.

🔥 Meanwhile at CGC…

You may have seen the wild spike in CGC slabs lately. But spoiler alert: it’s probably not due to a sudden wave of trust in their grading.

Nope. It might just be GameStop, quietly pumping out Pokémon “Power Packs” that include CGC slabs.

Yup—bulk-graded, mystery-slotted slabs inside blister packs.

So sure, CGC’s numbers are up… but it might be a cardboard sugar high.

😬 The Hobby’s Grading Crisis

We say we want:

• Transparency

• Consistency

• Reasonable turnarounds

• Modern tech

But we keep rewarding:

• Hype labels

• Influencer bias

• PSA 10 tunnel vision

Collectors won’t touch an Arena Club 9.5, but they’ll pay 3x for a PSA 10 with no explanation behind it. 🤔

🧠 Final Thought:

We’ve reached a point where the toughest grades get punished, and the meh labels get paid.

So here’s the real question:

Are we collecting cards… or collecting brand loyalty points?

#ArenaClub #GradingTruth #PSA #SlabBias #CGC #FanaticsWatch #CardCollector #SGC #BGS #DadCollectorVibes #JunkSlabEra #TheHobby #TransparentGrading #sportscardcollector #sportscardinvestor