1987 Fleer Baseball BBCE wrapped. Nice little surprise I had forgotten about in the abyss of unopened boxes in the last 6 years

2001 Upper Deck Premiere Edition Golf sitting in my unopened treasure trove from the last 5 years

Tiger Woods RC

2019 Bowman Mega in my absurd unopened packages

Alyx Effron | July 13, 2026

Presented By All Touch Case

Last week, Topps ignited one of the biggest debates the hobby has seen this year by announcing that its highly anticipated 2025-26 Topps Chrome Update Series Basketball retail release would ship without its traditional shrink wrap. The change - currently limited to retail format - removes the plastic seal before products are sent to customers in an effort to discourage scalping and improve access for collectors.

The announcement quickly became one of the most polarizing topics in the hobby. Some applauded the move, arguing that if unopened boxes become less attractive on the secondary market, more product may actually end up in the hands of collectors instead of resellers. Others raised legitimate concerns about product integrity, tampering, consumer confidence, and whether removing the seal simply creates a new set of problems without addressing the real issue.

Like many conversations in today’s hobby, there isn’t a clear right or wrong answer. From Collectors MD‘s perspective, the most interesting part of this discussion isn’t the plastic. It’s what the conversation reveals about the modern hobby.

For years, sealed boxes have represented more than just unopened packs. They’ve become assets. Investments. Inventory. A currency within the hobby. When a manufacturer changes something as simple as the packaging, the first questions many people ask aren’t about the cards inside. They’re about resale value. How will this affect comps? Will flippers still buy them? Will collectors trust them? Will the secondary market change?

None of those questions are inherently wrong. The hobby has always included elements of buying, selling, trading, and investing. Reselling isn’t new, and neither is speculation. The secondary market is woven throughout nearly every corner of the hobby – from online marketplaces and auction houses to card shows and live breaking. Each depends, to some extent, on a healthy ecosystem of buying, selling, and trading.

But moments like this give us an opportunity to pause and reflect on just how central resale value has become to the collecting experience. If removing a thin layer of plastic dramatically changes how we value a product, what does that say about what we’ve begun valuing most?

Sometimes the biggest conversations aren’t about the product itself – they’re about what the conversation says about our priorities as collectors.

It’s worth asking ourselves whether we’re primarily excited about opening the box – or about what the unopened box represents. That question isn’t meant to criticize anyone. It’s simply an invitation to pause, reflect, and perhaps think outside the box – no pun intended.

The reality is that manufacturers are constantly experimenting with ways to balance collector access, product security, environmental concerns, and the realities of a thriving resale market. Whether this particular approach succeeds or fails remains to be seen. But regardless of what happens with shrink wrap, one thing probably won’t change. As long as demand exceeds supply, there will always be a secondary market. There will always be resellers. There will always be collectors. There will always be disagreements about how the hobby should evolve. That’s simply part of modern collecting – and it’s hardly unique to trading cards. We see the same dynamics play out across many modern commerce industries. Whether it’s trading cards, sneakers, watches, collectibles, or concert tickets, scarcity inevitably creates a resale market.

The opportunity for each of us is deciding where our own priorities lie. Are we buying because we genuinely enjoy collecting? Or are we becoming increasingly focused on preserving value, chasing scarcity, and maximizing resale potential?

Ultimately, the conversation is less about who’s right or wrong and more about what matters most to each of us as collectors. What matters most is understanding what mindset is driving our decisions. Because intentional collecting isn’t determined by whether a box has plastic around it – it’s determined by the mindset of the collector opening it.

#CollectorsMD
The debate isn’t really about shrink wrap. It’s about the evolving identity of the hobby. As collecting continues to change, moments like these invite us to reflect on what we value most – and whether our decisions are being driven by enjoyment, intention, or the pursuit of the next opportunity.

—
Follow Us On Social: @collectorsmd
Join Our Support Group
Join Us On Mantel
Read More Daily Reflections

Support The CMD Foundation

This Daily Reflection is sponsored by All Touch Case, a premium display and protection solution designed to showcase your cards while keeping them safe. Use code COLLECTORSMD for 15% off your order. Collect. Protect. It’s a peace of mind.

https://collectorsmd.com/more-than-just-a-plastic-seal/

Those who know my collecting tendencies know it's impossible for me to leave wax unopened. But I have completed both 1988 Fleer and 1989 Topps (a couple times in '89 Topps' case), so these will probably be forever sealed.