Published November 14, 2025 | By Alyx E, Founder of Collectors MD
There’s a moment in every collector’s journey when the hobby stops feeling like a choice and starts feeling like a pull—an invisible force dragging you toward the next rip, the next bid, the next hit. At first it looks like excitement. Then one day you see it for what it actually is: two versions of you digging their heels into the same rope. One chasing relief, escape, and adrenaline. The other trying to hold on to meaning, memory, and the joy that originally brought you into the hobby. And in that tight, breath-held second, you realize the real battle isn’t in the cards or the breaks—it’s in you.
The line between intention and compulsion is razor thin, and most collectors cross it long before they realize it exists. Intention feels steady. You pick something up because it matters, and afterward you feel grounded, satisfied, and connected through nostalgia and meaning. Compulsion feels urgent. You’re buying to escape something, fill a void, or soothe that mix of stress, boredom, loneliness—that familiar ache you can’t quite name—and ten minutes later you’re staring at receipts and tracking numbers, wondering how you once again ended up here.
It’s the moment you finally see the rope for what it is—a constant pull between intention and compulsion, and you in the middle trying to choose who you want to be.
The hobby doesn’t warn you when you’ve crossed that line—nor does it care. It uses the same language to describe both lanes. A thoughtful PC pickup and a midnight spiral get stamped with the same W’s or L’s in the chat. But your nervous system knows the truth. Intention feels calm. Compulsion feels like a heaviness in your body, a rush that fades fast and leaves you emptier than before.
The shift back toward intention doesn’t require a meltdown or a rock-bottom moment. Most of the time it starts with a quiet realization: “I love this hobby—just not this version of it”. That’s not weakness. It’s awareness. It’s your internal grip on the rope strengthening again.
From there, you get to choose how you show up. For some, it’s practicing abstinence—stepping away entirely to give your mind and body space to reset. For others, it’s rebuilding structure: limits, boundaries, fewer triggers, intentional decisions, honest conversations with someone who can hold you accountable. Intentional collecting isn’t about showing you can muscle through the chaos—it’s choosing to stop fighting yourself in that endless pull between passion and impulse.
The internal tug-of-war doesn’t simply end one day. It’s a lifelong pull that shows up in different forms for all of us. But you still get to choose which side receives your strength, your honesty, and the version of yourself you want to become.
#CollectorsMD
When the rope starts burning your hands, it’s not a sign to pull harder—it’s a sign to pull with intention.
—
Follow us on Instagram: @collectorsmd
Subscribe to our Newsletter & Support Group
Join The Conversation On Mantel
Read More Daily Reflections